Is Surgery Right for Me? Decision Tree
Answer key questions to determine if surgical intervention is appropriate for your joint pain, or if non-surgical options should be explored first.
Note: This is an educational self-assessment tool, not a medical diagnostic. Results provide general guidance only and do not replace professional medical evaluation.
Where should we send your results?
Get your personalized results plus helpful resources delivered to your inbox.
What you'll receive:
- Your personalized assessment results
- Recommended next steps based on your answers
- Helpful resources about treatment options
We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe anytime.
Medical Disclaimer
This assessment is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment recommendations. The results are based solely on your self-reported answers and cannot replace a proper medical evaluation by a qualified healthcare provider.
This Is Not a Diagnostic Tool
- • Results do not diagnose any medical condition
- • Only a licensed healthcare provider can diagnose joint conditions through examination, imaging, and medical history review
- • Do not delay seeking medical care based on assessment results
- • If you are experiencing severe pain, sudden swelling, or inability to move a joint, seek immediate medical attention
About Treatment Suggestions
Any treatment options mentioned in your results are general information only. Treatment appropriateness depends on many factors including your complete medical history, current medications, allergies, and individual circumstances that only your healthcare provider can properly evaluate. Always discuss treatment options with your doctor before making healthcare decisions.
Insurance & Coverage: Coverage information referenced in results is general guidance only. Actual coverage varies by plan and is subject to change. Always verify coverage with your insurance provider or Medicare before scheduling treatments. Joint Pain Authority is not affiliated with Medicare, CMS, or any government agency.
About This Decision Tool
This assessment helps you evaluate whether surgical intervention is appropriate for your joint pain, or if exploring additional non-surgical options makes more sense for your situation.
It’s designed for people who are:
- Considering joint surgery (replacement, arthroscopy, etc.)
- Wondering if they’ve exhausted all conservative options
- Seeking clarity on the surgery vs. non-surgical decision
- Looking to make an informed, evidence-based choice
What You’ll Learn
- Whether your situation suggests non-surgical options should be tried first
- If you’ve truly exhausted conservative treatments (many haven’t)
- Whether you’re a candidate for advanced non-surgical treatments
- What questions to ask surgical and non-surgical specialists
- How to balance surgical risks against quality of life concerns
Understanding the Surgery Decision
The choice to have joint surgery is significant and often irreversible. While surgery can be life-changing for the right candidates, it also carries risks:
Surgical Considerations:
- Permanent alteration of joint anatomy
- Infection risk (1-2% for joint replacement)
- Blood clot risk
- 3-6 month recovery period
- Potential need for revision surgery (15-20% at 15 years for knee replacement)
- Significant cost (even with insurance)
Why Non-Surgical Options Matter:
- Hyaluronic acid injections can provide 6-12 months of relief
- Low risk compared to surgery
- No recovery time (most patients resume activities within 24-48 hours)
- Can be repeated if effective
- Medicare and most insurance plans cover them
- Surgery remains an option if they don’t work
When Surgery Makes Sense
Surgery may be the right choice when:
- You have severe, bone-on-bone arthritis confirmed by imaging
- You’ve genuinely tried comprehensive conservative treatment (PT, medications, injections) for adequate duration
- Joint damage is severe enough that non-surgical options are unlikely to help
- Pain severely limits quality of life despite maximum conservative treatment
- You’re healthy enough to tolerate surgery and recovery
- You have realistic expectations about outcomes
When to Try Non-Surgical Options First
Non-surgical treatments should be prioritized when:
- You haven’t tried all available options (HA injections, specialized PT, weight management)
- Your arthritis is mild to moderate (not bone-on-bone)
- You’re surgery-averse or have health conditions that increase surgical risk
- You need more time to prepare for surgery (improve fitness, arrange support)
- Previous treatments weren’t given adequate time or optimal delivery (e.g., non-guided injections)
- You’re within Medicare coverage criteria for HA injections
Key Questions to Consider
Before dismissing non-surgical options:
- Have I tried hyaluronic acid injections delivered with fluoroscopic (X-ray) guidance?
- Did I complete a full physical therapy program (not just 2-3 visits)?
- Have I addressed weight management if applicable?
- Did I give treatments adequate time to work (minimum 6-12 weeks)?
Before committing to surgery:
- What are the realistic outcome expectations?
- What’s the revision surgery rate for this procedure?
- What happens if I wait 6-12 months to try other options?
- Am I prepared for 3-6 months of recovery and rehabilitation?
- Have I gotten a second opinion?
Important Disclaimer
This assessment is for educational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment recommendation. The decision to pursue surgery or non-surgical treatment should be made in consultation with qualified healthcare providers.
Only a medical professional can properly evaluate your specific situation through physical examination, imaging review, and consideration of your complete medical history.
This tool cannot:
- Diagnose your condition
- Replace a medical consultation
- Guarantee treatment outcomes
- Account for all individual factors in your case
You should seek immediate medical attention if:
- You experience sudden severe pain or inability to bear weight
- You have signs of infection (fever, redness, warmth, swelling)
- You experience numbness, tingling, or weakness in the affected limb
- You have a traumatic injury requiring emergency evaluation
The information provided here represents general guidance based on evidence-based treatment pathways and clinical best practices. Your individual circumstances may warrant a different approach.