The Regenerative vs. Traditional Debate
If you’re researching knee injections for osteoarthritis, you’ve likely encountered two very different approaches: PRP (platelet-rich plasma) and hyaluronic acid (HA) injections.
PRP represents the newer “regenerative medicine” approach, marketed as helping your body heal itself. HA is the established, FDA-approved standard that’s been used for decades. Both aim to reduce pain and improve function—but they work differently, cost differently, and have very different levels of evidence supporting them.
Let’s cut through the hype and look at what the science actually says.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Factor | PRP Injections | Hyaluronic Acid (HA) |
|---|---|---|
| How it works | Growth factors stimulate healing | Lubrication and cushioning |
| FDA approval | No (off-label use) | Yes (multiple products) |
| Medicare coverage | No | Yes |
| Private insurance | Rarely covered | Usually covered |
| Evidence level | Moderate (mixed studies) | Strong (extensive trials) |
| Number of injections | Usually 1-3 | 1 or 3-5 (product-dependent) |
| Source | Your own blood | Avian or bacterial |
| Typical cost | $500-$2,500 per injection | $100-$300 with insurance |
| Procedure time | 30-45 min (includes blood draw) | 5-10 minutes |
| Pain level | Moderate (can cause flare initially) | Mild to moderate |
| Duration of effect | Variable (3-12+ months reported) | Up to 6 months |
| Standardization | Low (varies by provider/system) | High (FDA-regulated products) |
Hyaluronic Acid: The Established Standard
What It Is
Hyaluronic acid is a naturally occurring substance in healthy joints that provides lubrication and shock absorption. HA injections (also called viscosupplementation) replace depleted HA in arthritic joints.
How It Works
Advantages
Limitations
PRP: The Regenerative Alternative
What It Is
Platelet-rich plasma is concentrated platelets from your own blood, rich in growth factors. It’s injected into the joint with the goal of promoting healing and reducing inflammation.
How It Works (Theoretically)
Advantages
Limitations
The Evidence: What Does Research Show?
HA Injection Evidence
Hyaluronic acid has extensive, high-quality evidence:
- Multiple large randomized controlled trials showing efficacy vs. placebo
- Meta-analyses confirming modest but significant pain reduction
- Real-world effectiveness data from millions of patients
- Consistent safety profile across decades of use
- FDA approval based on rigorous clinical trials
Bottom line: HA works for many patients with mild-to-moderate knee OA. The effect is modest but real.
PRP Injection Evidence
PRP research shows mixed and inconsistent results:
Studies showing benefit:
- Some trials show PRP superior to HA for pain reduction
- Longer duration of effect reported in some studies
- Better outcomes in younger, more active patients
- May be more effective for early-stage OA
Studies showing no benefit or mixed results:
- Many studies find no significant difference vs. placebo
- High variability in outcomes between studies
- Inconsistent formulations make comparisons difficult
- Some show PRP equal to but not better than HA
Why the inconsistency?
- No standardization - PRP preparation methods vary widely
- Different platelet concentrations - affects outcomes
- Leukocyte content varies - may influence inflammation
- Activation protocols differ - impacts growth factor release
- Study quality varies - smaller trials, different endpoints
Bottom line: PRP shows promise but lacks the consistent, high-quality evidence that HA has. It may work for some patients, but we can’t predict who will benefit.
Cost Comparison: The Reality Check
HA Injection Costs
| Scenario | Typical Cost |
|---|---|
| With Medicare | $100-$200 (after deductible) |
| With private insurance | $100-$300 (copay/coinsurance) |
| Without insurance | $800-$1,500 per series |
| Annual cost (if repeated) | $200-$600 with insurance |
PRP Injection Costs
| Scenario | Typical Cost |
|---|---|
| With Medicare | Not covered - full price |
| With private insurance | Rarely covered - usually full price |
| Self-pay (per injection) | $500-$2,500 |
| Typical series (1-3 injections) | $1,000-$5,000+ |
| Annual cost (if repeated) | $1,000-$5,000+ |
Important Cost Considerations
PRP is almost never covered by insurance because:
- It’s not FDA-approved for osteoarthritis
- It’s considered investigational/experimental
- Medicare specifically excludes it from coverage
- Most private insurers follow Medicare’s lead
This means:
- You’ll pay the full cost out-of-pocket
- Costs vary widely by provider and region
- HSA/FSA funds may or may not be usable (check your plan)
- There’s no guarantee of benefit despite high cost
Which Works Better? The Honest Answer
What Meta-Analyses Show
Recent systematic reviews comparing PRP and HA have found:
Studies favoring PRP:
- Better pain reduction at 6-12 months
- More sustained benefit
- Superior function scores
- Better for younger, active patients
Studies showing equivalence:
- No significant difference in pain
- Similar functional outcomes
- Comparable safety
- Both better than placebo
The Standardization Problem
The biggest issue with PRP research:
Different studies use completely different PRP preparations:
- Platelet concentration: 2x to 10x baseline
- Leukocyte-rich vs. leukocyte-poor
- Single-spin vs. double-spin systems
- Activated vs. non-activated
- Different injection volumes and frequencies
This is like comparing different drugs. When studies use different formulations, we can’t really say “PRP works” or “PRP doesn’t work”—we’re comparing apples and oranges.
HA doesn’t have this problem - FDA-approved products are standardized and consistent.
Who Should Consider Each Option?
HA Is Likely Better For:
PRP May Be Worth Considering For:
The Procedure: What to Expect
HA Injection Procedure
- Preparation - Clean and sterilize knee (2 minutes)
- Numbing - Optional local anesthetic (1 minute)
- Aspiration - Remove excess fluid if needed (2 minutes)
- Injection - Insert HA into joint space (1 minute)
- Post-care - Apply bandage, provide instructions (2 minutes)
Total time: 5-10 minutes Pain level: Mild to moderate Recovery: Can walk immediately, avoid strenuous activity 48 hours
PRP Injection Procedure
- Blood draw - 30-60 mL of blood taken from arm (5 minutes)
- Centrifugation - Blood spun to concentrate platelets (10-15 minutes)
- PRP preparation - Extract platelet layer, may activate (5 minutes)
- Knee preparation - Clean and sterilize (2 minutes)
- Injection - Insert PRP into joint (2 minutes)
- Post-care - Rest, ice, activity restrictions (varies)
Total time: 30-45 minutes Pain level: Moderate (plus post-injection flare common) Recovery: Rest 24-48 hours, avoid strenuous activity 1-2 weeks
Safety and Side Effects
HA Injection Side Effects
Common (5-10% of patients):
- Temporary pain or swelling at injection site
- Warmth or redness
- Mild joint stiffness
Rare (less than 1%):
- Allergic reaction (if avian allergy)
- Infection
- Pseudoseptic reaction (inflammatory flare)
Overall: Very safe with low complication rates
PRP Injection Side Effects
Common (20-40% of patients):
- Post-injection pain flare (lasts 1-3 days)
- Swelling and stiffness
- Bruising at blood draw site
Rare (less than 1%):
- Infection
- Nerve damage (if poor technique)
- Allergic reaction (very rare with autologous blood)
Overall: Safe when properly prepared, but post-injection discomfort more common than HA
Making Your Decision
Questions to Ask Your Doctor
- Do I meet criteria for insurance-covered HA injections?
- What’s your experience with both HA and PRP?
- What results have you seen with PRP in your practice?
- What PRP system/preparation do you use?
- How much will PRP cost me out-of-pocket?
- Am I a good candidate for the regenerative approach?
- Should I try HA first before considering PRP?
Decision Framework
Start with HA if:
- You have Medicare or insurance coverage
- You want FDA-approved, evidence-based treatment
- Cost is a concern
- You prefer standardized, regulated products
- This is your first injection treatment
Consider PRP if:
- You’re younger and active (under 65)
- You have early-stage OA
- HA didn’t provide adequate relief
- You can afford $1,000-$5,000+ out-of-pocket
- You’re willing to try investigational treatment
- You find a provider with excellent PRP experience and standardized protocol
The Bottom Line
For Most Patients, HA Is the Practical Choice
Hyaluronic acid injections:
- Have FDA approval and decades of evidence
- Are covered by Medicare and most insurance
- Cost $100-$300 with insurance vs. $1,000-$5,000+ for PRP
- Provide consistent, standardized products
- Offer proven symptomatic relief for 6 months
PRP injections:
- Show promise but have inconsistent evidence
- Aren’t FDA-approved or covered by insurance
- Require significant out-of-pocket investment
- Lack standardization across providers
- May work for some patients, especially younger, active individuals with early OA
The honest truth:
For the vast majority of knee OA patients—especially those over 65 on Medicare—HA is the sensible first choice. It’s proven, affordable with insurance, and effective for many people.
PRP may be worth considering as a second-line option for younger, active patients who didn’t respond to HA and can afford to pay $1,000-$5,000+ for a treatment that might or might not work better.
Don’t let marketing hype convince you that “regenerative” automatically means “better.” The strongest evidence still supports hyaluronic acid for knee osteoarthritis.
Find Injection Specialists
Locate experienced providers who offer both HA and PRP injections and can help you make an informed choice.
Your information is secure. See our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.
Thank You!
We've received your request. A provider specialist will contact you within 1-2 business days to help you find the right care.
What happens next?
- 1 We'll verify your insurance coverage
- 2 Match you with quality providers in your area
- 3 Contact you to discuss your options
Questions? Browse our guides:
How to Choose a ProviderFrequently Asked Questions
Can I get PRP covered by insurance?
Very unlikely. Medicare explicitly doesn’t cover PRP for osteoarthritis, and most private insurers follow suit. Always check with your specific plan, but expect to pay out-of-pocket.
Which one lasts longer?
HA typically provides relief for up to 6 months. PRP duration is variable—some patients report 6 months, others 12+ months. We don’t have consistent data on PRP duration.
Can I combine HA and PRP?
Some providers offer combination treatments, but there’s limited evidence on whether this works better than either alone. It would also be expensive since you’d pay for both.
Is PRP better for younger patients?
Some evidence suggests PRP may work better in younger, more active patients with early-stage OA, but the data isn’t conclusive. Age and activity level may influence regenerative response.
Will PRP actually heal my cartilage?
Despite marketing claims, there’s no solid evidence that PRP regenerates cartilage in humans. It may reduce inflammation and pain, but cartilage regeneration remains unproven.
Should I try HA first before PRP?
Yes. Since HA is proven, covered by insurance, and much less expensive, it makes sense to try it first. If it doesn’t work, you can consider PRP as a second option.
How do I know if a PRP provider is reputable?
Look for:
- Board-certified orthopedic surgeon or sports medicine physician
- Uses FDA-cleared PRP preparation system
- Can explain their specific protocol and platelet concentration
- Has published outcomes or research experience
- Provides realistic expectations (not overpromising)
References
-
Comparative effectiveness of platelet-rich plasma vs hyaluronic acid. American Journal of Sports Medicine. 2021.
-
Systematic review and meta-analysis of PRP for knee osteoarthritis. British Journal of Sports Medicine. 2022.
-
Viscosupplementation for knee osteoarthritis: systematic review and meta-analysis. Osteoarthritis and Cartilage. 2020.
-
American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons Clinical Practice Guideline on treatment of osteoarthritis of the knee. 2021.
-
CMS National Coverage Determination: Platelet Rich Plasma. CMS.gov
-
FDA statement on PRP devices. FDA.gov
Get Evidence-Based Treatment Guidance
Stay informed about knee OA treatments with research-backed comparisons and updates.
Join 10,000+ readers. No spam.