Choosing Between Multi-Injection HA Products
If your doctor recommends hyaluronic acid (HA) injections for knee osteoarthritis, you’ll likely hear about several brand options. Supartz FX and Orthovisc are two established multi-injection products that have been helping patients for years.
Both are avian-derived, non-cross-linked HA products that restore joint lubrication—but they differ in molecular weight, dosing flexibility, and treatment protocols.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Factor | Supartz FX | Orthovisc |
|---|---|---|
| Injections needed | 3 or 5 (flexible) | 3-4 (weekly) |
| Molecular weight | Low-medium (0.62-1.17 million Da) | High (1-2.9 million Da) |
| Source | Avian (chicken comb) | Avian (chicken comb) |
| Volume | 2.5 mL per injection | 2 mL per injection |
| Cross-linking | No (native HA) | No (native HA) |
| Egg allergy safe | No | No |
| Duration of relief | Up to 6 months | Up to 6 months |
| Medicare covered | Yes | Yes |
| Manufacturer | Bioventus | Anika Therapeutics |
| FDA approval year | 2001 (original Supartz) | 2004 |
Supartz FX: Flexible Dosing Option
What It Is
Supartz FX is a low-to-medium molecular weight hyaluronic acid derived from chicken combs. It’s the updated formulation of the original Supartz, offering flexibility in treatment duration based on patient response.
Advantages
Considerations
Best For
- Patients who may benefit from extended dosing (5 injections)
- Those whose doctors want to adjust treatment mid-course
- Patients with prior positive response to Supartz
- Anyone seeking a well-established HA product
Orthovisc: High Molecular Weight Alternative
What It Is
Orthovisc is a high molecular weight hyaluronic acid (similar to the natural HA in healthy joints) derived from chicken combs. It’s designed to provide substantial cushioning and lubrication with a standard 3-4 injection series.
Advantages
Considerations
Best For
- Patients preferring higher molecular weight formulation
- Those who can attend 3-4 weekly appointments
- Patients with prior positive response to Orthovisc or similar HMW products
- Anyone seeking a product with substantial clinical data
The Science: Does Molecular Weight Matter?
Understanding the Difference
The molecular weight difference between these products has led to theoretical benefits for each:
Lower MW Theory (Supartz):
- Better tissue penetration
- More similar to synovial fluid viscosity
- May trigger beneficial biological responses
- Potentially less inflammatory
Higher MW Theory (Orthovisc):
- More like healthy joint HA
- Better shock absorption
- Longer residence time
- Greater cushioning effect
What Research Shows
Clinical trials comparing different molecular weight HA products have found:
- Similar pain relief across molecular weight ranges
- Comparable duration of effect (both ~6 months)
- Individual variation - some patients respond better to one formulation
- No consistent superiority of one molecular weight over another
Bottom line: Both molecular weights work effectively. Your individual response matters more than the theoretical differences.
Clinical Evidence Comparison
Supartz FX Studies
Research on Supartz (and its updated FX formulation) has demonstrated:
- Pain reduction comparable to other HA products
- Functional improvement in daily activities
- Safety profile consistent across thousands of patients
- Repeat treatment effectiveness - can be used multiple times per year if needed
Orthovisc Studies
Clinical trials for Orthovisc have shown:
- Significant pain reduction compared to placebo
- Improved function lasting up to 6 months
- Good tolerability with low adverse event rates
- Efficacy in moderate to severe knee OA
Head-to-Head Comparison
While direct comparisons between Supartz and Orthovisc are limited, studies comparing similar molecular weight products suggest no significant difference in clinical outcomes.
Dosing Flexibility: A Key Difference
Supartz FX Protocol
One of Supartz FX’s unique features is flexible dosing:
3-Injection Protocol:
- For patients responding well after 3 weeks
- Preferred by some insurance plans
- Shorter treatment duration
5-Injection Protocol:
- For patients needing extended treatment
- May provide longer-lasting relief
- Allows for gradual improvement assessment
Your doctor can decide mid-treatment whether to stop at 3 or continue to 5 injections.
Orthovisc Protocol
Orthovisc follows a standard multi-injection protocol:
- 3-4 weekly injections (typically 3)
- Fixed schedule determined at start
- Consistent with most HA products
Insurance and Cost Comparison
Medicare Coverage
Both Supartz FX and Orthovisc are covered by Medicare Part B when medically necessary:
- Documented knee osteoarthritis
- Failed conservative treatment (typically 3+ months)
- Meets Local Coverage Determination (LCD) requirements
Cost Considerations
| Factor | Supartz FX | Orthovisc |
|---|---|---|
| Office visits | 3-5 | 3-4 |
| Copays (typical) | 3-5 × $20-50 | 3-4 × $20-50 |
| Injection fees | Per visit | Per visit |
| Total series cost | Similar | Similar |
Important: The 5-injection Supartz series may cost more in total copays, but the per-treatment cost is typically similar.
Allergy Considerations
Important: Both Are Avian-Derived
Supartz FX and Orthovisc are both derived from chicken combs.
If you have allergies to:
- Eggs
- Chicken
- Feathers
- Other poultry products
You should avoid both products and ask your doctor about non-avian alternatives like Euflexxa, Durolane, or other bacterial fermentation-derived HA products.
Always inform your doctor about any allergies before receiving HA injections.
Making Your Decision
Questions to Ask Your Doctor
- Do I have any avian allergies that would rule out both products?
- Which product do you have more experience using?
- How many injections do you typically recommend?
- What does my insurance prefer or cover better?
- Have you seen patients respond differently to different molecular weights?
- Can we adjust the Supartz dosing if I respond well after 3 injections?
Decision Framework
Choose Supartz FX if:
- You want dosing flexibility (3 or 5 injections)
- Your doctor prefers to adjust treatment based on response
- You’ve responded well to lower MW products before
- You’re comfortable with up to 5 appointments
Choose Orthovisc if:
- You prefer higher molecular weight formulation
- You want a standard 3-4 week protocol
- Your doctor has more experience with Orthovisc
- Your insurance has a preference for this product
The Bottom Line
Both Are Effective Options
Supartz FX and Orthovisc are both proven HA treatments for knee osteoarthritis:
- Clinical outcomes are similar
- Duration of relief is comparable (~6 months)
- Both are covered by Medicare and most insurance
- Both have established safety profiles
The choice often comes down to:
- Your doctor’s experience and preference
- Dosing flexibility needs (3 vs. 3-5 injections)
- Insurance coverage and costs
- Your schedule and ability to attend multiple appointments
The most important factor: Working with a skilled provider who can properly administer whichever product you choose. The injection technique and your provider’s experience matter as much as the product itself.
Find HA Injection Specialists
Locate experienced providers who offer Supartz FX, Orthovisc, and other HA products.
Your information is secure. See our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.
Thank You!
We've received your request. A provider specialist will contact you within 1-2 business days to help you find the right care.
What happens next?
- 1 We'll verify your insurance coverage
- 2 Match you with quality providers in your area
- 3 Contact you to discuss your options
Questions? Browse our guides:
How to Choose a ProviderFrequently Asked Questions
Can I switch from one to the other if the first doesn’t work?
Yes. If you don’t respond well to one HA product, your doctor may recommend trying a different brand or molecular weight. Some patients respond better to specific formulations.
How soon can I get a repeat treatment?
Most doctors recommend waiting at least 6 months between HA treatment series. Medicare typically covers one series per knee per year.
Which one lasts longer?
Clinical studies show similar duration for both products—typically up to 6 months of pain relief. Individual results vary.
Are there any other options if I’m allergic to both?
Yes. Non-avian HA products include Euflexxa, Durolane, and other bacterial fermentation-derived options that are safe for patients with egg or chicken allergies.
Does one hurt more than the other?
Pain from injection is usually related to injection technique, not the product itself. Both have similar injection volumes (2-2.5 mL) and are generally well-tolerated.
References
-
Supartz FX (sodium hyaluronate) Prescribing Information. Bioventus.
-
Orthovisc (high molecular weight hyaluronan) Prescribing Information. Anika Therapeutics.
-
Efficacy of different molecular weight hyaluronan products. Clinical Medicine Insights: Arthritis and Musculoskeletal Disorders.
-
Long-term safety and efficacy of hyaluronic acid injections. Orthopedic Reviews. Full Text
-
CMS LCD L39529 - Intraarticular Knee Injections. Medicare Coverage Database
Stay Informed on Knee OA Treatments
Get evidence-based comparisons and updates on treatment options delivered to your inbox.
Join 10,000+ readers. No spam.