Can Gel Injections Delay Knee Replacement? What 182,000 Patients Reveal
A landmark study of 182,022 patients reveals gel injections delay knee replacement by an average of 370 days. Patients receiving 5+ treatment courses delayed surgery by 3.6 years on average.
By Joint Pain Authority Team
The Bottom Line
The largest study ever conducted on this question followed 182,022 patients with knee osteoarthritis. The findings are striking:
- Patients receiving gel injections delayed knee replacement by 370 days longer than those who didn’t
- The more treatment courses patients received, the longer they delayed surgery
- 22.2% of patients who received 5+ courses delayed surgery by 4.5+ years
- Statistical significance was overwhelming: p < 0.0001
This isn’t marginal data. It’s the strongest evidence we have that gel injections can meaningfully postpone major knee surgery.
The Question Everyone With Knee Arthritis Asks
If you’re dealing with knee osteoarthritis, you’ve probably wondered: Can I avoid or delay knee replacement surgery?
It’s the question that keeps people up at night. Knee replacement is major surgery with real risks. Recovery takes months. The prosthetic won’t last forever. And once you’ve had one knee replacement, you may face another later in life.
So when patients hear about gel injections (hyaluronic acid, also called viscosupplementation), they want to know: Do these actually buy me time before surgery?
Thanks to one of the largest medical database studies ever conducted, we finally have a clear answer.
What the Largest Study Shows
Study Overview: 182,022 Patients
In 2015, researchers published a landmark study analyzing data from a massive U.S. claims database containing approximately 79 million patients.[1]
From this database, they identified 182,022 patients with knee osteoarthritis who eventually underwent total knee replacement (TKR). Then they compared outcomes based on whether patients had received hyaluronic acid (HA) injections before their surgery.
Study Parameters:
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Total patients analyzed | 182,022 |
| Source database size | ~79 million patients |
| Study type | Retrospective claims analysis |
| Primary outcome | Time from diagnosis to knee replacement |
| Statistical significance | p < 0.0001 |
The Core Finding: 370 Extra Days
The researchers measured how long it took patients to progress from their osteoarthritis diagnosis to total knee replacement surgery. The difference between the groups was substantial:
Time to Total Knee Replacement:
| Patient Group | Median Days to TKR |
|---|---|
| No gel injections | 114 days |
| Received gel injections | 484 days |
| Difference | 370 days (over 1 year) |
This means patients who received gel injections waited more than four times longer before needing knee replacement surgery compared to those who didn’t receive injections.
In practical terms, that level of statistical significance means the result is extremely unlikely to be due to chance. The pattern is real.
The Dose-Response Effect: More Courses = More Delay
Perhaps the most compelling finding was what researchers call a “dose-response relationship.” Simply put: the more courses of gel injections patients received, the longer they delayed surgery.
Time to Surgery Based on Number of HA Courses:
| HA Treatment Courses | Mean Time to TKR |
|---|---|
| No HA injections | 0.7 years |
| 1 course | 1.4 years |
| 3 courses | 2.3 years |
| 5+ courses | 3.6 years |
What This Pattern Tells Us
The Long-Term Delayers
One of the most striking findings was what happened to patients who received five or more treatment courses:
Among patients receiving 5+ courses of HA injections:
- 22.2% delayed total knee replacement by 4.5+ years
- Average delay was 3.6 years before surgery
That’s more than one in five patients gaining nearly half a decade before needing major surgery.
Why Delaying Knee Replacement Matters
You might wonder: if someone eventually needs a knee replacement anyway, why does delaying it matter?
The answer involves understanding what knee replacement surgery actually means—and what can go wrong.
The Reality of Knee Replacement Surgery
Knee Replacement Facts:
| Factor | Reality |
|---|---|
| Surgical success | High—about 90% get significant pain relief |
| Patients with residual pain | 20% still have some pain after surgery |
| Average prosthetic lifespan | 15-20 years (may need revision) |
| Hospital stay | 1-3 days typically |
| Full recovery time | 3-6 months |
| Return to normal activities | 6-12 months |
The Risks You Avoid Each Year You Delay
Every year that knee replacement is safely postponed means avoiding:
The 20% Problem
One statistic that surprises many patients: 20% of people who undergo total knee replacement still have pain afterward.
The surgery works well for most people, but it’s not a guarantee of a pain-free life. Some patients trade one type of pain for another. Some have complications. Some are simply among the percentage for whom the procedure doesn’t deliver complete relief.
Every year you can delay surgery is a year you keep your natural knee—and a year you avoid the possibility of being in that 20%.
The Prosthetic Lifespan Issue
Modern knee prosthetics are remarkable pieces of engineering, but they don’t last forever. Most last 15-20 years with typical use.
The math problem:
- If you get a knee replacement at 55, you may need a revision surgery at 70-75
- Revision surgery is more complex, with longer recovery and higher complication rates
- Each revision removes more bone, making future options more limited
The solution: If you can delay your first knee replacement until 65-70+, you may never need a revision. Your prosthetic could last the rest of your life.
Who Benefits Most From Delaying Surgery
Not everyone is in the same situation. Some patients will benefit more from a delay strategy than others.
Patients Under 55
Why younger patients especially benefit from delay:
- Longer life expectancy = higher likelihood of needing revision surgery
- 17.8% of patients under 55 need revision within 18 years
- Every year of delay reduces lifetime surgical burden
- Implant technology improves each year you wait
A 50-year-old who delays knee replacement from age 55 to age 65 may go from facing 2-3 lifetime surgeries to just one.
Patients With Moderate (Not End-Stage) Arthritis
Patients Who Want to Avoid or Delay Surgery
Some patients have strong preferences against surgery—whether due to fear, religious beliefs, bad prior experiences, or simply wanting to preserve their natural joint as long as possible.
For these patients, knowing that gel injections can provide years of additional time before surgery offers peace of mind and a clear path forward.
Patients With Surgical Risk Factors
For these patients, every year surgery can be delayed is a year to potentially improve underlying health conditions—or simply a year of avoided risk.
Is Avoiding Surgery Entirely Possible?
Here’s the honest answer: For most people with progressive knee osteoarthritis, some level of surgical intervention will eventually be needed.
But that’s not the right question to ask.
The Better Questions
What About “Bone-on-Bone”?
Some patients are told they’re “bone-on-bone” and must have surgery immediately. While severe arthritis with complete cartilage loss is serious, the term is often overused and can be misleading.
Key points:
- Many patients labeled “bone-on-bone” still respond to conservative care
- Imaging findings don’t always correlate with symptoms
- Some patients with severe X-ray findings function well; others with mild findings struggle
- The decision should be based on function, pain, and quality of life—not just images
If you’ve been told you need surgery immediately, it’s reasonable to ask whether a trial of gel injections might buy you time.
How to Maximize Your Delay
If your goal is to postpone knee replacement as long as safely possible, research suggests a multi-pronged approach works best.
The Combination Strategy
Evidence-Based Approaches to Delay Surgery:
| Intervention | Role |
|---|---|
| Gel injections (HA) | Restore joint lubrication, reduce friction |
| Physical therapy | Strengthen muscles supporting the knee |
| Weight management | Every pound lost = 4 pounds less stress on knee |
| Activity modification | Reduce high-impact stress while staying active |
| Anti-inflammatory approaches | Manage pain and inflammation |
| Bracing | Provide mechanical support when needed |
The Importance of Sustained Treatment
The 182,000-patient study showed that more treatment courses = more delay. This suggests that viewing gel injections as a one-time treatment misses the point.
For patients committed to delaying surgery:
Frequently Asked Questions
How long do gel injections typically provide relief?
Most patients experience relief for 6-12 months per treatment course. Some patients report longer-lasting effects, while others may need more frequent treatment. The key finding from the research is that sustained treatment over time produces the best results for delaying surgery.
Does Medicare cover gel injections?
Yes. Medicare Part B covers hyaluronic acid injections for knee osteoarthritis. Coverage requires documentation of failed conservative treatment (like physical therapy or anti-inflammatory medications). Repeat treatments are allowed every 6+ months if medically necessary.
Are gel injections painful?
Most patients describe the injection as mild discomfort similar to any joint injection—a brief pinch and pressure. Using imaging guidance (fluoroscopy or ultrasound) improves accuracy and often reduces discomfort. Most patients return to normal activities the same day.
What if gel injections don’t work for me?
Not every patient responds to gel injections. If you don’t experience benefit after a proper treatment course, it may indicate that your arthritis is too advanced for this approach to help. At that point, discussing surgery with your doctor is appropriate.
Can I get gel injections if I’ve already been told I need a knee replacement?
Often, yes. Unless you have truly end-stage arthritis with complete bone collapse or severe deformity, a trial of gel injections may be worth considering. Discuss with your doctor whether you’re a candidate.
How do gel injections compare to cortisone shots?
Both provide pain relief, but they work differently. Cortisone reduces inflammation quickly but effects are shorter-lasting (weeks to months). Gel injections supplement joint fluid and typically provide longer relief (6-12 months). Cortisone has also been associated with cartilage damage with repeated use, while gel injections have not.
What to Discuss With Your Doctor
If you’re considering whether gel injections might help you delay knee replacement, here are questions to ask:
The Bottom Line
What 182,000 Patients Teach Us
The evidence is compelling:
- Gel injections delayed knee replacement by 370 days (over a year) compared to no treatment
- Patients receiving 5+ courses delayed surgery by an average of 3.6 years
- 22.2% of committed patients delayed surgery by 4.5+ years
- The statistical significance was overwhelming (p < 0.0001)
What this means for you:
If you’re facing the prospect of knee replacement, gel injections offer a real opportunity to delay that surgery—potentially for years. Every year of delay means:
- Avoiding surgical risks for another year
- Keeping your natural knee functioning
- Allowing implant technology to improve
- Reducing your lifetime likelihood of revision surgery
Knee replacement is an excellent surgery when truly needed. But the best surgery is one you can safely postpone until the right time. For many patients, gel injections make that possible.
Explore Your Options
Find providers who offer gel injections and can discuss whether this approach is right for your situation.
Your information is secure. See our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.
Thank You!
We've received your request. A provider specialist will contact you within 1-2 business days to help you find the right care.
What happens next?
- 1 We'll verify your insurance coverage
- 2 Match you with quality providers in your area
- 3 Contact you to discuss your options
Questions? Browse our guides:
How to Choose a ProviderReferences
-
Altman R, Lim S, Steen RG, Dasa V. Hyaluronic Acid Injections Are Associated with Delay of Total Knee Replacement Surgery in Patients with Knee Osteoarthritis: Evidence from a Large U.S. Health Claims Database. PLoS One. 2015;10(12):e0145776. Full Text
-
Ong KL, Anderson AF, Niazi F, Fierlinger AL, Kurtz SM, Altman RD. Hyaluronic Acid Injections in Medicare Knee Osteoarthritis Patients Are Associated With Longer Time to Knee Arthroplasty. J Arthroplasty. 2016;31(8):1667-73.
-
Park JG, et al. Association between intra-articular hyaluronic acid injections and time to total knee arthroplasty. BMC Musculoskelet Disord. 2024;25:706.
-
Evans JT, et al. How long does a knee replacement last? A systematic review and meta-analysis of case series and national registry reports with more than 15 years of follow-up. Lancet. 2019;393(10172):655-63.
-
CMS LCD L39529 - Viscosupplementation Therapy for Knee. Medicare Coverage Database
Stay Informed About Non-Surgical Options
Get the latest research on treatments that can help you manage knee osteoarthritis and delay surgery.
Join 10,000+ readers. No spam.
Related Resources
More on Surgery Delay
- 75% of “Bone-on-Bone” Patients Delayed Surgery 7+ Years
- Gel Injections vs Knee Replacement: Cost Comparison
Understanding the Treatment
- The FDA-Approved Treatment 80% of Patients Have Never Heard Of
- The Clinical Evidence: What 6,000+ Patients Show
- How Long Do Gel Injections Last?
Insurance and Coverage
- Does Medicare Cover Gel Injections? 2026 Guide
- Why 30% of Insurance Plans Don’t Cover Gel Injections
Hub Pages
Topics
Enjoyed this article?
Get more insights like this delivered to your inbox weekly.
Join 10,000+ readers. No spam.